Mobility and Access Committee for Scotland (MACS)

Navigation

  1. Overview
  2. Aims of MACS
  3. Documents
  4. Meetings
  5. Members' biographies
  6. Register of Interests
  7. Secretariat and contact details
  8. Recruitment
  9. Achievements
  10. Subgroups

Overview

The Mobility and Access Committee for Scotland (MACS) was established in 2002 and is an advisory non departmental public body. The Convener and Members are appointed by the Minister for Transport and the Islands.

MACS was formally constituted under section 72 of the Transport (Scotland) Act 2001. Prior to this advice was provided by the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee (DPTAC) on a UK wide basis and there was no equivalent Scottish body.

The role of MACS is set out in the Act as being to:

  • consider matters about the needs of disabled persons in connection with transport that the committee think are appropriate
  • advise the Scottish Ministers about those matters that the committee think are appropriate.

The Committee has 15 members with various skills, knowledge and experience gained through their fields of expertise and lived experiences. Members have collective responsibility for the effective operation of MACS, and are led by the Convener.

The Convener gives active and effective leadership, direction, support and guidance to ensure that MACS delivers its functions effectively and efficiently, consistent with Ministers’ priorities.

Partnership for Change

MACS signed up to the Scottish Government’s Partnership for Change and has committed to working towards 50/50 by 2020.

Meetings, consultations and guides

The MACS Committee meets formally 4 times a year and the minutes of these committee meetings are available.

MACS also responds to consultations and calls for evidence to make sure the views of disabled people are heard and taken into consideration when developing policies and designing services in relation to travel. This includes all modes of transport and the surrounding infrastructures. MACS responses to consultations and calls for evidence are also available.

The Committee has produced various guides and good practice documents to help with designing accessible environments and services and the removal of barriers encountered by disabled people when travelling.

"MACS believes in a Scotland without the barriers that isolate and exclude disabled people from making their choice of successful door to door journeys"

MACS Publication Scheme

Aims of MACS

Overall Aim

In the founding legislation the Scottish Ministers have defined the overall aim for MACS as follows:

“MACS will consider such matters relating to the needs of disabled persons in connection with transport as the Committee think appropriate and give advice to Scottish Ministers”.

The Convener shall aim to ensure that MACS’ policies and actions supports the wider strategic policies of the Scottish Ministers.

Vision

MACS believes in a Scotland without the barriers that isolate and exclude disabled people from making their choice of successful door to door journeys. 

Remit

To give Scottish Ministers advice on aspects of policy, legislation and practice affecting the travel needs of disabled people.

To take account of the broad views and lived experiences of disabled people when giving advice.

To encourage awareness amongst disabled people in Scotland of developments which affects their mobility, choices and opportunities.

To work closely with SG and ensure our work programme complements the work being undertaken by the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee (DPTAC), the Equality and Human Rights Commission and other organisations , voluntary and statutory.

To promote the travel needs of disabled people with designers, including transport planners and operators, so that these are fully taken into account in the development of vehicles and infrastructure and delivery of services.

To monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of our work against the above aims and objectives in improving travel opportunities for disabled people in Scotland.

MACS aims are that disabled people should be able to: 

  • Obtain and use easily accessible information to plan journeys
  • Get from where they live to reach public transport services unobstructed
  • Access those services with whatever support and help are necessary
  • Enjoy the journey in comfort and safety
  • Satisfactorily complete the journey

These aims assist with delivering on the pledges within Scotland’s first ever National Accessible Travel Framework published in 2016 (Going Further). This framework is designed to ensure that:

  1. More disabled people make more successful door to door journeys more often
  2. Disabled people are more involved in development and improvements in transport policies, services and infrastructure
  3. Everyone involved in delivering transport information, services and infrastructure will help to enable disabled people to travel
  4. Disabled people feel comfortable and safe using public transport - this includes being free from hate crime, bullying and harassment when travelling

MACS works with various partners to deliver its aims and strategic objectives. This includes, but is not limited to, Disabled People, The Scottish Government, The Scottish Human Rights Commission, The Equality and Human Rights Commission, National, Regional and Local Transport Providers, National, Regional and Local Public Authorities, Disabled Persons Organisations and Disability Organisations.

Working in partnership with these organisations MACS seeks the following outcomes:

  • Ensure travel information is accurate and accessible.
  • Remove barriers to the accessibility of public transport services and infrastructure.
  • Identify and promote best practice in all areas of public transport provision.
  • Advise that all public transport staff undergo appropriate disability, equality and awareness training.
  • Ensure that public transport networks make full use of all potential service providers and transport options are in place for people who cannot get to or use conventional public transport services.

Documents

Annual report

MACS Code of conduct 

Workstreams' workplans

2019/20

Previous years

Consultation responses

Reports and examples of good practice

MACS Thematic Subgroups

Motability

Transport to Health

Meetings

The Mobility and Access Committee (MACS) meets quarterly in Victoria Quay, Edinburgh. Meetings commence at 11:00 (refreshments from 10:45) unless otherwise indicated.

Upcoming MACS meetings

2020

  • 21 January (Main Committee)
  • 18 February (Leads Meeting)
  • 19 March (Development Day)
  • 21 April (Main Committee)
  • 19 May (Leads Meeting)
  • 21 July (Main Committee)
  • 18 August (Leads Meeting)
  • 27 August (Development Day)
  • 20 October (Main Committee)
  • 17 November (Leads Meeting)

2021

  • 19 January (MACS Meeting)
  • 16 February (MACS Leads Meeting)
  • 18 March (MACS Development Day)
  • 20 April (MACS Meeting)
  • 18 May (MACS Leads Meeting)
  • 20 July (MACS Meeting)
  • 18 August (MACS Leads Meeting)
  • 26 August (MACS Development Day)
  • 19 October (MACS Meeting)
  • 9 November (MACS Leads Meeting)
  • 25 November (MACS Scoping Day) (TBC)

Members of the public are welcome to attend MACS meetings. The Secretariat requires a minimum of one week's notice of attendance. Depending on the venue up to 5 places are available. Places will be allocated on a first come, first served basis.

If you wish to attend please contact macs@gov.scot or telephone 0131 244 0923.

Minutes of previous meetings

 

Past minutes of MACS meetings are available via the UK web archive.

Members' biographies

Naghat Ahmed

Naghat AhmedNaghat is a Law and Accountancy graduate and a committee member for the Law Society of Scotland Client Protection Sub-committee.

Her current role at Glasgow City Council includes both programme and project management. She has previously worked on policy and strategy development, equality and diversity, change management, corporate governance and utilising project methodologies. She previously worked in the Commission for Racial Equality and NHS 24, specialising in equality and diversity.

Naghat is a carer for relatives who have disabilities.

Linda Bamford

Linda Bamford

Linda Bamford is the Convener of the Mobility and Access Committee for Scotland (MACS). Her career background is mainly in NHS Scotland, initially as a psychiatric and general nurse before moving into Para medicine with the Scottish Ambulance Service.  After 13 years as a frontline paramedic in Glasgow Linda moved into management holding various senior management positions within the Scottish Ambulance Service (SAS). Her NHS career spanned over 30 years.

She was heavily involved in Accident and Emergency ambulance service provision in various areas in Scotland (urban, rural and Islands) and led on the previous Patient Transport Service Redesign Strategy.

She is the recipient of two queens medals. One for “Long Service and Good Conduct – Emergency Services”, and the second for “Dedication to the NHS”.

Linda had to take early medical retirement after several lots of surgery for a spinal cord injury.

She is involved in Children’s Hearings Scotland and is also a qualified counsellor.

She was previously the Chair of Spinal Injuries Scotland (SIS), an organisation she got involved with after her spinal cord injury and rehabilitation, and remains one of their Ambassadors.

Linda is the Convener for Disability Equality Scotland, a national Disabled Person’s Organisation (DPO) aiming to achieve full access and inclusion for disabled people in Scotland.

As well has holding her Ministerial appointed as Convener with the Mobility and Access Committee for Scotland (MACS), Linda was recently also appointed by Scottish Ministers as a Commissioner with the new statutory Scottish Poverty and Inequality Commission.

Audrey Birt

Audrey BirtAudrey started her career as a nurse, in particular in community and practice settings. After leaving clinical practice she developed a broad experience in redesign and improving health and social care.

Following this she moved to third sector and has extensive senior executive experience, including being the Director for Scotland of Breakthrough Breast Cancer and the National Director for Diabetes UK Scotland. Audrey was a founder member of the Health and Social Care Alliance and was Chair of the Health and Social Care Alliance for 10 years, where she now is an Associate Director of the Academy; a Programme in the Alliance working with her passion, focussed on transformation of health and social care.

She's a coach and consultant on organisational change as well as a regular blogger on health and disability issues, informed by her own experience. Until her spinal damage she enjoyed walking, especially with her lurcher Cara. She loves to write, in particular with her creative writing group, which meets in galleries around Edinburgh. She has two adult children, step grandchildren, several grandogs and is very delighted to have a grandchild on the way.

Marsali Craig

Marsali CraigMarsali has been a Trustee and Director of the MS Society and a Director of Aberdeen based North-East Sensory Services. She sat on the Aberdeen City Children’s Panel for two terms and currently works as a volunteer with the Faculty of Health and Social Care at RGU Aberdeen.

Marsali has professional skills and experience as a Social Worker and as a Solicitor and has a wide personal experience of travelling as a disabled person. She was appointed as a member of the Equalities and Human Rights Commission Scotland Committee in December 2017.

She represents the Scotland Committee on the Equality and Human Rights Commission Disability Advisory Committee.

Joanne Fairweather

Joanne FairweatherJoanne was appointed as a MACS member on 1 October. She has a slight learning disability and is a member of Enable Scotland, an organisation for people with learning disabilities and family carers.

Joanne is involved with ACE and ENABLE Scotland. ACE is an Active Community of Empowered people with learning disabilities, who challenge barriers to an equal society for every person with learning disability in every community across Scotland. She was elected by her local Elgin ACE members to represent their group at the National ACE meetings. Through her lived-in experience and her work with ACE, she has an understanding of local and national issues for disabled people.

A lot of the work Joanne is involved in, both locally in the Moray area and nationally, is about transport for people with a disability. She has represented the views and promoted the needs of people who have disabilities at national and local meetings. These include meetings with Transport Scotland and the Scottish Commission for Learning Disability. As someone who has a learning disability she has first-hand knowledge of the barriers faced when using transport.

Joanne has three sons: Ian, who is 20, Neil, 19 and Keith, 14. Her hobbies include: doing jig-saws, and playing on her tablet, watching TV and going for walks. She enjoys meeting people.

Sheila Fletcher

Sheila FletcherSheila has wide experience in the provision of public transport and associated infrastructure, having worked for over 25 years in the public and third sector. She is involved with her local Access Panel and Third Sector Interface.

Sheila left the Community Transport Association in 2017 after 14 years supporting third sector transport providers throughout Scotland. She currently volunteers with 2 groups who provide local community transport services and is also involved with groups who provide day care in the community. She is a member of the Chartered Institute of Logistics and Transport.

Susan Fulton

Susan FultonSusan has worked in a Local Authority setting for many years and has experience in a number of different roles diversifying into the field of accessibility and inclusive design in 2004.   Susan is passionate about working with others to create and develop environments that are both accessible and inclusive to as many of us as possible and believes that initial engagement with the potential end user at the earliest possible stage is the key to achieving this.

Susan brings her experience both as a Chartered Surveyor and Access Consultant to the Committee coupled with her current and past membership of various groups, panels and Boards working towards accessible and inclusive places and spaces for everyone to access.   

Susan is currently a member of Network Rail’s Built Environment Accessibility Panel, a member of the National Register of Access Consultants Advisory Group and a Director of Disability Equality Scotland.

David Hunter

David HunterDavid is an independent consultant with Not for Profit Planning. He has over thirty years’ experience in a wide variety of voluntary and professional roles promoting accessible transport. He was a full-time volunteer with Manchester Community Transport before becoming the first Director of the London Dial a Ride Users Association. He developed a range of accessible and sustainable transport services for Lothian and Edinburgh Councils for ten years before leading strategy and business planning at the National Library of Scotland.

He has degrees in Politics and Social Policy and was appointed an Associate Research Fellow at Edinburgh Napier University’s Transport Research Institute in 2015.

His interests include social policy research, consumer involvement in public services and in making streets and public places inclusive. He is a member of Living Streets, the Institute of Transport and Logistics and the Scottish Accessible Transport Alliance.

Hussein Patwa

Hussein PatwaHussein was elected as an RNIB Scotland Member Representative in 2011 and to the RNIB Scotland Committee shortly thereafter. He was co-opted onto the strategic Living with Sight Loss Programme Board and also sits on the Travel, Shopping & Control of Money Programme Board within the same organisation.

He is a member of the Scottish Accessible Transport Alliance with a particular interest in accessible rail and local bus transport. Hussein has a background in Business Management, Innovation & Change and Internet Information Systems with e-Business.

Keith Robertson

Keith RobertsonKeith is a Royal Navy Veteran. He was invalided out of the forces in 1973 after an accident that left him disabled and a paraplegic wheelchair user.

He is a graduate of Heriot Watt University and has professional expertise in the field of accessibility and design of Inclusive Environments.

Keith is the General Manager of Wheelchair s for Ukraine.

Hilary Stubbs

Hilary StubbsHilary has had a career spanning almost 40 years in Local Government. She has specialised in the field of business support including HR, Finance, performance management and risk management. On secondment to the Audit Commission, Hilary undertook the role of Inspector in Local Authorities across the UK.

As a Board Member of West Highland College, Hilary chairs the Board’s Audit Committee and hopes to bring her knowledge of Board Governance and audit to this role.

Hilary is a regular traveller on public transport, especially the ferry services. Having worked with young people with special needs she hopes to influence the provision of accessible transport for all sectors of the community. Hilary was County Commissioner for Scouting in County Durham and has been involved in charity work especially with St Cuthbert’s Hospice in Durham and Dorothy’s well project, Tanzania, where she was a founding trustee.

Hilary graduated from St Mary’s College, Durham University and remained in Durham until she retired to Isle of Arran.

Fraser Sutherland

Fraser SutherlandFraser champions consumer rights in Scotland and across the UK. He has a wide range of consumer research and advocacy experience in a variety of markets including financial services, communications and retail.

Mr Sutherland authored Citizens Advice Scotland’s report on rural bus provision and led their campaign against unfair practices in the private parking industry. He is passionate about protecting vulnerable consumers, including those with a disability, and championing the issues faced by those in remote and rural Scotland.

He is Co-Chair of the Chartered Trading Standards Institute Consumer panel and is a member of the Chartered Institute of Public Relations.

Michael Tornow

Michael TornowMichael was appointed in summer 2017 as Senior Health Improvement Officer at NHS Health Scotland and is currently leading portfolios of work on housing and dementia. Before that, he worked for NHS Health Scotland as Health Improvement Officer, supporting the NHS and others to promote physical activity.

Mr Tornow previously worked for NHS Health Scotland’s Equality Team, and before that for the Disability Rights Commission and Glasgow Housing Association. He has a BA Honours Degree in Sociology from Stirling University and a Post-Graduate Diploma in Housing, also from Stirling.

He has a Master’s Degree in Equality and Human Rights from Glasgow University and is currently studying Physical Activity for Health part-time at Edinburgh University.

In 2013, Mr Tornow became a Trustee of the charity, Partners in Advocacy, and is currently a member of the National Institute for Health Care Excellence’s Public Health Advisory Committee, which is updating good practice guidelines on making people more physically active.

John Whitfield

John WhitfieldJohn was born with a severe hearing loss and wears bi-lateral hearing aids and lip reads. His eyesight deteriorated due to Retinitis Pigmentosa and he has been registered blind for over 30 years.

Over the years his work with Deafblind Scotland (DbS) has involved a considerable amount of travelling. Due to his sight loss he has to utilise every mode of transport necessary to fulfil his role and has used ferries, trains and where necessary taxis when buses are not available.

He has a wealth of experience around accessibility and transport modes. He has also represented Deafblind Scotland on a number of meetings to address accessibility issues for dual sensory impaired people.

Register of Interests

Secretariat and contact details

A secretariat within Transport Scotland serves MACS. The secretariat is located in Victoria Quay in Edinburgh.

The Secretariat responsibilities include: circulating information to members informing members of consultations updating the MACS website arranging and organising meetings circulating meeting papers supporting the Convener and preparing minutes of meetings processing payments of allowances and expenses co-ordinating appropriate representation by Committee members at external events facilitating media handling through Transport Scotland's Communication Office

The MACS Secretariat can be contacted at:

Transport Scotland
Area 2D Dockside
Victoria Quay
Edinburgh
EH6 6QQ

Telephone: 0131 244 0923

E-mail: macs@gov.scot

Recruitment

There are no current MACS vacancies.

Videos - What MACS means to its members

Marsali Craig

 

David Hunter

Achievements

MACS Turkish visit - discussion in progress around the tableMACS Turkish Visit

A change from the usual business of MACS came in June 2018 with the visit of a party of civil servants, academics, consultants and disabled people’s organisations from Turkey. The delegation is developing a national strategy for accessible transport in Turkey, a project funded by the EU, and was keen to understand Scottish approaches to making transport inclusive, and MACS’ role in particular.

We met at Waverley Bridge in Edinburgh to take a Majestic Bus Tour and take the opportunity to show the visitors accessible facilities available on Lothian Buses, especially the “Quantum System” for securing wheelchairs. This system is currently thought to be a market leader and has had excellent reviews from wheelchair users.

This was a nice and informal introduction before the main meeting, which took place in Victoria Quay. Linda Bamford, the MACS Convener, and Karl Zaczek, a Team Leader of the Accessible Travel Framework Implementation Team of Transport Scotland, gave a brief overview of MACS’ role and of the Accessible Transport Framework, followed by an open discussion.

Many questions concerned the difference between legal enforcement on the one hand and exerting influence on the other. We were asked if our Equalities legislation had helped us in promoting and enforcing Accessibility in public transport. We confirmed that the Equalities legislation had been extremely helpful for disabled people in the UK. However, we had to explain that as an advisory body, MACS has no powers to ensure compliance with laws and guidance, but is influential in raising standards through engagement with operators, planners and professionals.

The Turkish delegation were also interested to hear about the many good practice guides available in Scotland, and we were able to provide links to a number of resources that should be of practical use in Turkey.

This was an excellent opportunity for MACS to meet and exchange ideas with people from Turkey who share our interest in promoting accessible travel for disabled people. We also made some rewarding links for future engagement.

MACS Turkish visit - talking about wheelchairs near Waverley StationDavid had some very useful discussions with the leaders of the Project. Marsali shared time and banter with Ayhan, a member of the Turkey Disabled Peoples’ Confederation and an Advisor to the Ministry of Family and Social Policy. He joked that her wheelchair was fit only for a disabled person - his was for basketball players! In his youth he had played wheelchair basketball for the Turkish national team. He thought all wheelchairs should be “active” wheelchairs. He described how he has campaigned for wheelchair accessible buses on all routes – a campaign that we could all identify with.

It was rewarding to have MACS’ expertise recognised internationally, and the delegation was keen to maintain contact with MACS and Scotland in general as they complete their project. We will also be interested to hear how the Turkish approach to inclusive transport develops, and to see what lessons Scotland might also learn from the Turkish experience.

Marsali Craig and David Hunter
MACS members
29 June 2018


MACS hosts a successful 4 Nations meeting in Edinburgh

MACS was delighted to host representatives from the Disabled Persons Advisory Committee (DPTAC) and Northern Ireland’s Inclusive Mobility and Transport Advisory Committee (IMTAC) at Victoria Quay on 8 August 2019. 

We had invited them to a “4 Nations” meeting to discuss how we could work together
to achieve our common aim of making transport accessible for all throughout the UK.

This was a really useful meeting for all.  Keith Richards, the Chair of DPTAC, Bert Bailie (Chair) and June Best (Vice Chair) of IMTAC, together with their secretariats and sponsor civil servants met with MACS Convener, Linda Bamford, Vice Convener Hilary Stubbs and Workstream Leads: David Hunter, Shelia Fletcher and Marsali Craig.We were also joined by our Secretariat and our own Sponsor, Claire Smith, Head of Transport Accessibility, Transport Scotland.

MACS’ Convener, Linda Bamford, chaired the meeting.

This was a really useful meeting for all involved. The morning was one of introductions and sharing ideas, with MACS pitching first to explain some of the changes within the committee structure, the benefits of this and the successes gained by working more widely and directly (to some envy of other chairs) across Ministerial portfolios and Transport Scotland Directorates. The Convener explained the approach to this was based on transport as an enabler.

It was confirmed that all the committee roles were on an advisory capacity only.  None of the committees have enforcement powers. 

As we discussed our roles, committee structures, our successes, our frustrations and our plans, it became apparent that we could learn a lot from each other. Astrid Davis, from the Welsh Government, said she was now thinking of trying to set up a Wales Committee on a similar model to MACS.

  • In an afternoon discussion, we identified many common themes and concerns.  In particular:
  • Now was a good time to get things done to achieve change through the accessible travel agenda and the need for this was being noticed across the UK.
  • The need for engagement with disabled people at the concept and design stage of any project to have more of a chance of ‘getting it right’ first time.
  • Good quality training for Transport Providers is essential – designed and delivered with the involvement of disabled people.
  • There is a need to move away from the modal and silo ways of working  and encourage more discussion,
    learning and good practice sharing on holistic door to door travel. 

A shared priority concern among all three committees was the need to push for Public Sector Vehicle Access Regulations (PSVAR) to be revised before the proposed date of 2028. MACS was especially keen on this issue because of the growing concerns in the rural areas where inaccessible coaches are often used on registered bus routes. Therefore the committee  asked for support from its UK counterparts, and we all agreed that a joint approach could be successful in persuading Department for Transport (DfT)  to undertaking a sooner review.

This meeting was such a success that we agreed we should meet again – probably in Belfast next time. Belfast was a popular choice, mainly due to Glider buses, so nicely advertised by Sean Coulter, so we are all keen to see them in action!

Attendees:

Scotland
Linda Bamford, MACS Convener (Chair)
Hilary Stubbs, MACS Vice Convener
Marsali Craig, MACS
Sheila Fletcher, MACS
David Hunter, MACS
Aga Lysak, MACS Secretary
Claire Smith, Transport Scotland
Robert Wyllie, Transport Scotland

England
Alison Franks (DfT)
Keith Richards, DPTAC Chair
Rajesh Mistry, DPTAC Secretary

Northern Ireland
Bert Bailie, IMTAC Chair
June Best, IMTAC  Vice Chair
Michael Lorimer, IMTAC Secretary
Sean Coulter  DfI Accessibility Team

Wales
Astrid Davis, Walsh Government

Subgroups

Transport to Health

MACS has recently been focusing on identifying the barriers disabled people face when planning, booking, identifying what’s available and using transport to medical appointments and healthcare facilities.

To better understand the current barriers and respond to disabled people’s concerns, MACS has established an internal sub-group for the purpose of evidence gathering and mapping out the current situation across the country. MACS also asked Disability Equality Scotland (DES) to run a weekly poll (in November 2018 and August 2019) asking members whether they experienced any problems with booking or using transport to health services. Based on the responses DES produced a report summarising people’s experiences – please see below.

The committee would like to share its findings with a variety of stakeholders (from policy makers, Health Boards, Local Authorities, The Scottish Ambulance Service through to taxi drivers) at the meeting which is going to be held in November 2019 in Glasgow.

The event is going to be of a focussed open-discussion style, run by a facilitator, which will help the group to identify and talk through the biggest issues and, through constructive discussions, help to come to some conclusions on proposed solutions. 

Findings from this event will form a base for the advice MACS is going to give Scottish Ministers, in terms of making recommendations that would tackle the current problems.

The main objective of the event is to share MACS’ findings and hear from all involved, so collectively ideas can be brought forward that would make the service more effective and fit for purpose.

If you would like to share your experience of using the transport to health services, or provide feedback or comments on that issue, please email MACS at MACS@gov.scot.